For “recruitniks”, the college football equivalent of Star Wars nerds, late December to the first week in February is an extremely exciting/maddening time. We look at recruiting sites, follow Twitter feeds, post on message boards (I must admit, I perused some message boards for the first time, desperate to find any kind of info that “reliable sources” might have, and truth be told, I’d probably rather be caught masturbating than on a message board), etc. Despite the sadness of this, the fact is recruiting well is the most important thing a college football program can do–period. So, if you are a crazy enough fan, it makes sense that you could eventually start following where the best of the best high schoolers are looking to play their college football. It’s almost like reaching for hope. Scouring recruiting sites to learn what recruiting experts who do nothing but watch high school film think of your school’s efforts is way to gauge the future. If Rivals.com says a school has a bright future, well, it takes away the sting of another 6-win season. Shoot, college football and sports in general are as much about hope and looking for a brighter future as anything else in life.
Perhaps nothing stirs hope in the recruiting world like the the fight for the commitment of a recruiting service’s #1 quarterback. Possibly gaining the pledge of the creme de la creme at the sports most important position is sort of like gaining the keys to a million dollar inheritance at 18. Your football team has the world by the balls, the rest is just details. This year, for the Irish and many others, that player was Gunner Kiel. His story was “The Gunner Kiel Saga”.
Pro-style quarterback. Good athleticism. NFL-size before he even enrolls in college. Big arm. Accurate arm. Mr. Indiana in football. 40 total touchdowns this year (28 throwing), and only 4 picks. All of the big boys offered him. Basically, college coaches wanted him like rap video producers want models with big booties.
The Irish thought they had him. The kid was an in-state player, grew up as an Irish fan, and his uncle Blair even played quarterback for Notre Dame in the late 70’s/early 80’s. Also, with an unsettled quarterback situation, the kid had a shot to play right away. Oh, and finally, he and the family understood the value of a Notre Dame degree.
Then, he confused the hell out of everyone when he committed to…Indiana. Yep, the Indiana Hoosiers. With no intention of playing basketball. WTF? When he came to his senses and reneged on his Indiana commit, the smart money was on the Irish once again.
Then it was down to three. ND (football and education). Vanderbilt (education). LSU (football, really, really good football). Gunner wanted to enroll in January, so he had to announce soon. But, just when many thought he would just go ahead and get going with ND, the sounds of silence were all that was heard. This kid was playing it close to the vest. Word came out he would choose before Christmas. Then it was by Christmas. Nothing. Finally, two days after Christmas, Gunner pulled the trigger.
LSU was the winner. Too bad for ND.
I can’t say ND hearts are broken, but it is never nice to miss out on a 5-star. The truth is, there will be another Gunner Kiel next year, and the next, and the next. But, Brian Kelly is really working hard to build up momentum in his program, and with recruiting being more high profile than ever, it is not good for perception to be spurned by such a high-profile recruit. Kelly will have to hit on some of the other big names left (Neal, Shumate, Wright) by February 1st to ensure a top 10 class (whether you believe in rankings or not, look at the names of the schools every year in Rivals’ “top 10s”–they tend to be pretty good teams).
Finally, the fans that scream about ND being the best choice due to the balance of football and academics should take note. Kiel is a kid that knows the score, knows the numbers, knows who graduates players, and still, he chose the elite football school in the premier football conference. No disrespect to LSU’s academics (a kid can be a success with a degree from many institutions of higher learning), but when compared to ND and Vanderbilt, Gunner clearly made a football first choice (he talked about how excited he was to play in the SEC to get ready for the NFL). That is fine. In fact, that is what many of the nation’s elite base their choice on. The situation is what it is. Elite kids want (and believe wholeheartedly) they will have a football future. If “The Gunner Kiel Saga” teaches ND fans anything, it is that academics are fine, but, for the best recruits, football is king. The Irish football program will have to stand with these giants of the playing field, on the field, if it is ever to become an “it” program among the very best recruits in the nation again.