Can We Learn Anything From The Miami Mess?
August 18th, 2011 . by adamnThe Miami Hurricanes. They do excess like nobody else. I mean nobody. They always have (there’s something about South Beach). If VH1 ever did a “Behind the Hurricanes”, the episode would make Ozzy Osbourne feel like he needed to take a shower to rub off the filth. And this was a man who would drink another’s pee to show how hard he could party.
The Hurricanes and Nevin Shapiro have taken over college football two-and-a-half weeks before the season gets underway. And rightfully so. There hasn’t been scandal like this since the days of SMU, or Barry Switzer at Oklahoma. Shapiro was a Miami conduit that got some of the best players in program history wined, dined, paid, and laid. Oh, and coaches too. Engagement rings? No problem. Or, if that’s not your fancy, we can go in the opposite direction and get you an abortion too. Shapiro was sleazy and versatile. Like Pat Forde said, “the Wal Mart of sleaze”.
Beside this being such a story because of previously-known scandals from Eugene to Columbus (hey things are tough for college football right now), this intrigues me because it’s Miami. The bad boys of college football. Man, how I would have loved to be in my prime as a college football fan during the “Catholics vs Convicts” era. When NBC branded their programs as “must-see tv”, they must have borrowed the idea from this series. A rivalry that got shut down because, get this, it was too intense. If the system was around at the time, the ND-Miami game would have garnered an NC-17 rating. Not too much brings me more joy than Notre Dame winning. A close second is Miami losing. Some would say Florida’s Disney World is “the happiest place on earth”. I’d say wherever the stadium Miami lost at was even happier.
That’s beside the point. In the aftermath of the scandal allegations, is there a point (or points)? The Blarney thinks there are a few, so it’s time to put some out there. This is what I think can be learned from the Miami mess:
There’s at least a little bit of dirt everywhere. Not like Miami, but I sincerely believe that every program has “gray areas” that they could be held accountable for. Even honorable programs. The dirt comes to the surface more these days because technology gives the means to uncover information more than ever. When you “play to win the game” it is human nature to look for any edge possible, and the leads to the lines of proper conduct being straddled. This might mean as little as a $20 handshake here and there for some, or the orgy of misdeeds seen in the Miami case.
It’s our fault. I mean you and I, and fans everywhere. We put the value in college football by tuning in every Saturday, combing through news stories, posting on message boards or blogs, following recruiting, and engaging in damn near drunken fist fights at a local watering hole because a college football discussion got too heated. Without us, ESPN wouldn’t rule half the world, and networks and schools wouldn’t be getting their wallets stuffed to the point that powerful people with less-than-normal scruples would do almost anything to ensure said programs keep stuffing wallets. Everyone is richer and happier that way. Fans fuel the fire. And the market. (This point goes hand-in-hand with human nature looking for any edge in competition.)
Don’t f–k with Yahoo’s Charles Robinson. If you do very bad things, this investigative journalist will find out. Rule breakers need not worry about the Boogeyman haunting them, but they do need to worry about Robinson.
Notre Dame’s rebirth under Brian Kelly just got a little easier. The Irish are going back to the toughest schedule in the nation formula it had under Holtz-adding teams like Oklahoma, Texas, and Miami to traditional toughies in the future. Well, Miami just made it a little easier in ‘12 , ‘16 and ‘17.
If they really want to stop this, no tolerance is the way. I don’t know if this is what should be done, but if the powers that be want to put a serious dent in these happenings, no tolerance is the way to go. In the current system, the wrong-doers often skate, and the innocent that come after the fact pay the price. Make the punishment so steep for major violations and neglect (not minor things like dinners and small benefits), that nobody will want to take the chance. If you steal in America, you might get a slap on the wrist, in an Islamic country you’ll get a hand taken off at the wrist. You want a school to police it’s players? Make it care too much to be negligent. Start from the neck up. Fire presidents, athletic directors, and head coaches on the spot when egregious things happen. A school gets an unfair advantage due to agent and booster gifts? Subject the school to million dollar fines. Money talks.
Those are the Blarney’s learnings, but what will the people with power learn?
Miami is the biggest test case of a major rule violater. The NCAA is going to have to study it closely (and the rest of the cases), reach importante conclusions, and decide where to go from there. It’s time to either tighten the grip on schools, or loosen them, and rethink the concept of amateurism. Which way will they go?