NFL Combine Notes-And What They Mean (Part II)
March 2nd, 2010 . by adamnThe NFL has wrapped their annual Dog and Pony show. The show to see who the next NFL stars will be. Heights have been measured, weights have been weighed, forties have been run, buffets on top of naked ladies have been trotted out, swords have been swallowed, pyrotechnics have exploded and etched a picture (of gladiators in shoulder pads wrestling 3-headed beasts to the ground) into the night sky. (Hey, the combine is an Event, baby. That’s right, with a capital “E”.)
Players stocks have risen, player stocks have fallen, in large part due to talents that don’t even show themselves on a football field (”Jones, from as complete standstill, jump for that first down now, damnit!”). GM’s have seen these test results-and some (I’m looking in your direction, Al Davis) will fall in love with them, and forget about the three years worth of game film that preceded these showings. In fact, “Arbitrary test results over on-field production” could be the combine’s slogan.
True, the combine is a gathering of more information that might prove to be valuable, and certainly is a measure of athletic ability, but should never overshadow what talent evaluators see when the pads are on. Management should always remember this.
Even knowing this, the fact is that the combine is a huge event, and a means to gain the NFL more exposure in the off-season, so it is here to stay. And, since it is still worth talking about, here are some random combine notes gathered by the Blarney, complete with a deciphered meaning.
Scouts think Jimmy Clausen is “arrogant”.
What it Means:
Maybe he is. So are all great athletes (and any other person who sees themselves as a “player” in their industry). He is also talented, smart, and coachable enough to go from throwing double digit picks in his sophomore year to throwing only three as a junior. I don’t know Jimmy Clausen at all-but “arrogance” is a pretty poor reason to drop him on draft boards.
Ndamukong Suh verticals 35.5″, and runs slightly under 5 seconds.
What it Means:
Again, film is more important. The jumping ability shows lower-body explosiveness, but Suh made his name by tossing around o-lineman like rag dolls.
Tennessee’s Eric Berry runs a 4.4.
What it means:
He comes out aces in film (what he does on the field), and athletic ability. 1st round pick, and future NFL stud, count on it.
USC’s Taylor Mays ( 6-3, and 230lbs, at least), runs a 4.24!! Wait, it’s actually a 4.43. Plus he broad jumps 10′5″.
What it means:
First, why bother with hand-timing? Humans are not accurate in measurement (guys know what I am talking about) in any way. Second, the guy is a stud of an athlete, but he must have also have the TBWA Chiat/Day marketing team behind him to make him look like a machine (reports of a electronically-timed 4.3 40 at USC, as well as a broad jump of almost 11 and a half feet)! Mays doesn’t play as well as he tests (he even got torched by Dane Sanzenbacher), but should last in the NFL for awhile.
4 defensive linemen, including USC’s Everson Griffen, and TCU’s Jerry Hughes, run in the 4.6’s.
That, combined with great (for Hughes) actual game ability, show that this is not your grandfather’s NFL. Defensive lineman really do run like safeties these days.
Florida’s Joe Haden run a 4.57 (that’s almost a 4.6 for a corner, which is slower than some defensive ends).
What it means:
SEC speed?! Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha! (Pause for breath.) Hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahhahahaha! Seriously kid, don’t leave your house without your game film, ever.
ND safety Kyle McCarthy places second in shuttle and cone drills, but runs a 4.65.
What it means:
Nothing that we didn’t know already for Kyle. He is a good, but not great athlete, that can certainly do some things on the field. His film will show that he is good enough to be involved in the play, but not good enough to make a play. A Special Teamer, and maybe get on the field in some nickel-type situations.
Look, the combine is great, and we love to see what athletic achievements these kids can accomplish. And I know I just laughed at Joe Haden, but he can still be a good pro (though that bad performance might cost him some dollars). But, the combine is sizzle, and what these kids do when the helmets are on (and the lights are dark in the film room) is the steak that is really needed.