From Day 1…
March 31st, 2011 . by adamnNotre Dame football has been down a long time. A really long time. The last time Notre Dame football was Notre Dame football, Bill Clinton was in office, and America was soon to find out you could do more with cigars than smoke’em. That’s just too long.
The theories to why ND has been are many, and I won’t get into most of them here. We simply don’t know for sure whether they have credence or not. However, there is one theory, that I will go into, and it is one that I believe to be 100% true.
Notre Dame (contrary to what Beano Cook would say) simply was not getting the material. Well, not elite material anyway. Not a guy that came in from day 1, and made a coach say, “Holy hell, we need to get him on the field…like yesterday.”
You can talk about player development, and leadership, and this and that, but the fact is, Notre Dame was getting solid to very good players. That’s it. Not players that would make a coach smirk to himself because the raw material was so great. Not the best of the best.
Nobody like Marcus Lattimore.
Nobody like Gerald McCoy.
Nobody like Adrian Peterson.
Or Reggie Bush.
Or Andy Katzenmoyer.
When Cedric Benson came to play for Texas, it cause Mack Brown to quip “Joe Paterno used to say that you lose a game for every freshman you start, so maybe we’ll wait until the second play to put Cedric in.”
John Cooper was similar in his assessment of Katzenmoyer (paraphrasing from an old SI): “So Andy comes in as a freshman (chuckling), and he’s bigger than any of our other linebackers (more chuckling), he’s stronger than any of ‘em (even more chuckling), and he’s faster than any of ‘em (rolling on the ground laughing). So, with all due respect to the other guys, we had to find a spot for Andy Katzenmoyer.”
Do either of those sound like the assessment of a Notre Dame player? Maybe Mike Floyd, but that’s it.
And therein was the problem.
Now it’s Brian Kelly’s turn to revive the program. We all know what he did in recruiting this past year. And looky looky (from Irish Illustrated) what a coach is saying about one of those recruits (Aaron Lynch):
“He was faster than everybody, he was bigger than everybody, so he was obviously running around them attacking the quarterback,” said Elston of Lynch’s high school career. “He did the same thing on run plays. He just ran around people. He didn’t know how to defeat the block. He just went out and made plays.”
Lynch is still making plays, and Elston is hardly fretting about what may be a bit of a shortcoming in his game at the present time.
“He’s going to be able to do it all,” said Elston of Lynch, who lined up with the No. 2 unit Wednesday during the early portion of practice. “We’re very encouraged by Aaron, and he will definitely be able to defeat a block and stop the run.”
Hmmm. At the coaching clinic this past weekend, Urban Meyer looked at Lynch, Ishaq Williams, and Lous Nix, and said “we would have loved to have had them at Florida”. (Note that all the players mentioned were young guns, guys that ND hasn’t been able to get until recently.)
So, coach Kelly, the evidence is there, the writing is on the wall. You want to turn this thing around? Keep getting guys that can play from day 1.
