Is The NFL Combine Fools Gold?
February 24th, 2009 . by adamnSo, you’ve heard the old adage-”Never judge a book by its cover”? Well, for a weekend in February, NFL scouts and personnel men do that exact opposite. They look at the pretty cover-and they judge it. Harshly. The pretty cover is a variety of physical tests-40 yard dash, vertical jump, broad jump, bench press. The book is the 3 or 4 years of on field accomplishments and film that a given player produced on Saturdays. At the end of the day, the combine (pretty cover) usually take precedence over the player’s career (the book).
In other words, a running back that never rushed for 1000 yards in a single college season can run a sub 4.4 forty, and jump from questionable to a first round pick. Yes, the combine is a pressure- packed situation that directly affects the pay days of these future NFLers. This event is huge mainly because the Simon Cowells of the NFL landscape easily fall in love with athletic feats like running 40 yards faster than a Ferrari reaches 60mph, or throwing a football threw bullet-proof glass. Any player that can shine from a “did you just see that” standpoint is dubbed for stardom.
Unfortunately, these physical measures can often be fools gold. It may look shiny, but it ain’t worth a damn.
It ain’t worth squat because these Olympian efforts don’t always translate to the football field. What good is a quarterback that than launches passes with the velocity of a bazooka if he can’t read where the linebacker is blitzing from? So a GM wants to add track speed to his team? He can take Usain Bolt to be a starting wide receiver if he wants. Then, he can watch him run by somebody only to drop a sure touchdown because his hands are made of leather repellent (Available at Target, but it just sits on the shelf because who doesn’t like leather?). I’ll take Larry Fitzgerald (who ran like he trained for his 40 yard by entering a Twinkie eating competition one hour before), and watch touchdown passes stick to his hands like velcro. The point is that the NFL combine measures a certain skill set, but ignores other skill sets that are just as valuable (if not more) to success in the league.
In this years combine, Florida Wr Percy Harvin ran slower than expected in his 40 drills. It may hurt his draft status. Would anyone that has seen this kid kid play doubt for a second he can have a major impact on someones offense? OSU Rb Chris Wells barely broke a 4.6 in his dash time. He will no longer be the top rated back in this draft. Well, if you’ve seen this tank leave tread marks over entire defenses on Saturdays, it is obvious he is made for the NFL.
I realize the combine has its purpose. Athletic ability is important, and the combine is a way to separate the great athletes from the merely good ones. For example, you can be outstanding in college because you are stronger than 90% of your opponents, but strong (by itself) is not good enough against comparable athletes. There must be more.
But, while the combine can show who has more, remember it is not the final answer. Don’t let a stopwatch overshadow what your eyes have seen all along.